Teachers & Staff

Say Hello to the dedicated teachers and staff!

Sue Dillman - Teacher

Sue graduated from UW-Oshkosh with an Elementary Education degree and a minor in coaching. She then received her synodical certification through the LCMS's Colloquy Program in 2002. She has been honored to serve the Lord by teaching at Trinity Oshkosh for over 30 years, and continued His call at New Hope Christian School in fall 2025. Sue has four children, living both near and far. She cherishes time with her family and friends - biking, camping, and traveling. She has a passion for sharing the love of Jesus through classroom teaching.  

Alyssa Kieffer - Teacher

Alyssa graduated from UW-Oshkosh with an Elementary Education degree and a minor in Communication Studies. For several years, she has served the families of the Oshkosh School District. She has gone above and beyond as a third grade teacher by serving on support and leadership teams that help students succeed academically and socially. As new members of New Hope Lutheran Church, she, her husband, and daughter are excited to join the Eagle family. She looks forward to the opportunity to incorporate her faith into the curriculum as she guides the preschoolers into all that God has planned.

Shelby Anglemyer - Literacy Intervention Tutor

Shelby is certified in the Wilson Reading System and trained in the Barton Reading System. She has over 30 years of experience working with children and families as a kindergarten teacher, creating and directing an in-home daycare, and tutoring. She loves meeting and getting to know families, helping children recognize their strengths, and to grow in their faith. The Lord has graced her with a combination of patience and creativity that has led her to assist children in reading skills as they gain confidence, while having fun in the process. Shelby is passionate about building reading skills using multi-sensory, interest based methods, and believes that everyone can enjoy reading.

Shelly Scott - Custodian

Shelly is very excited and grateful to be part of the New Hope family. She is very friendly and loves meeting new people, so always feel free to say hello or wave when you see her in the halls. Shelly takes pride in her work, which she does in excellence for the glory of God. Shelly has three kids and twin granddaughters. She enjoys thrifting, crafting, and is learning to sew. She enjoys the simple things in life and believes that God is so good - all the time!

Questions?

Questions for anyone featured on this page? Simple click the button below and get in touch with us!